ผู้ชายที่ดี

ยินดีต้อนรับสู่วิกิพีเดียภาษาไทย

ยินดีต้อนรับคุณ ผู้ชายที่ดี สู่วิกิพีเดียภาษาไทย หน้าต่อไปนี้อาจเป็นประโยชน์แก่คุณ:

มือใหม่ขอแนะนำอย่างยิ่งให้คุณเริ่มจากแก้หรือต่อเติมบทความที่มีอยู่แล้วก่อน ไม่ควรรีบสร้างบทความด้วยตัวเองเพราะมักไม่ผ่านและถูกลบ

แนะนำเว็บ

และ

เรียนรู้การแก้ไข (ขอใช้เวลาอ่านไม่นานเพื่อให้ทราบพื้นฐาน)

อีกทางหนึ่ง อ่านหน้า การเข้ามีส่วนร่วมในวิกิพีเดีย ซึ่งสรุปทุกอย่างไว้หน้าเดียว

ฉันอ่านหมดแล้วยังไม่เข้าใจเลย

ถามที่แผนกช่วยเหลือ หรือ หรือ ใช้ แชตดิสคอร์ด

อย่าลืมลงชื่อในหน้าพูดคุย โดยการพิมพ์ --~~~~ จะปรากฏชื่อและวันเวลา

Hello ผู้ชายที่ดี! Welcome to Thai Wikipedia. If you are not a Thai speaker, you can ask a question in our Guestbook.

-- New user message (คุย) 19:51, 27 พฤษภาคม 2562 (ICT)

ATFX

Hello. I would like to inform you that the "ATFX" draft article was moved to ฉบับร่าง:เอทีเอฟเอ็กซ์, in order to allow you to continue working on it. Other editors, however, remain concerned that the article may not qualify the Notability issues. You are advised to read the guidelines there (it's for the English Wikipedia, though we also relied on it if the guidelines in Thai Wikipedia is not sufficient). I would like to also express concern that another of your article (อแมนด้า มัสตาร์ด) was previously nominated for deletion at English Wikipedia due to the questionable notability, though I do not tag for the deletion outright and instead left the {{ขาดความสำคัญ}} (Notability) tag in place for attention of other editors.

Please note that this message is being sent in English, as I believed you may be more familiar with English based on the structure and choice of word used in the article. You may reply in English or Thai at your convenience. Thanks. --G(x) (คุย) 12:05, 18 กรกฎาคม 2562 (ICT)

Hello. Please do not recreate the page (at ATFX) in the main namespace (that is, the page without any prefix) without addressing the concern made by other editors and myself. As a reminder, your Draft page remains at "ฉบับร่าง:เอทีเอฟเอ็กซ์", and you should continue working on it instead of submitting the same draft without substantial revision to make it comply with Wikipedia guidelines. I will now flag the page for deletion in order for you to work on the draft. Please feel free to ask me if you have any questions. Thank you. --G(x) (คุย) 18:28, 25 กรกฎาคม 2562 (ICT)

G(x), Thank you for the insight. Anyway, I am still confused. The first attempt I made on this topic was deleted because it had few references. The title was "ATFX" in Thai language. I was asked to generate more references. Now, I re-worked this and added more notable references and republished with the title "ATFX". I guess, the page has enough references to scale through. If not, could you highlight what is missing and what I need to do so that I can keep working on the draft. Thanks ผู้ชายที่ดี (คุย) 19:39, 25 กรกฎาคม 2562 (ICT)

@ผู้ชายที่ดี และ Vkimanis: I would like to note that the quality of the reference you used is poor. FX Daily Info and some other sources published the article based on the "sponsored" banner, which means it is not publishing the content on its own merit. Any sources which say that ATFX itself is the source must be removed. I have checked some other references and found that some of it just doesn't reflect the actual content it attempted to verify (for example, the reference that mentioned former ATFX CEO only mentioned a brief portion of the company, and more on the former CEO itself).

What I concerned more is that the article must pass the notability criteria. The general guideline is that the article will warrant its own page "If a topic has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject" (emphasis added). So far, many of the sources, while reliable, is not independent. The topic itself also not received significant coverage. Some source (such as the service review) may be considered "significant", like the Blockonomi article, but there need to be more source than that, some that is not ATFX-sponsored stories and is "reliable" with mention to the subject itself. --G(x) (คุย) 12:23, 26 กรกฎาคม 2562 (ICT)

Hello. If you want to contest the deletion, you must do it on the talk page of the respective article (Talk:ATFX). Unless you have substantially revised the article to address the concern described here, you should not remove the deletion tag or make it hidden using the <!-- and -->. Thank you. --G(x) (คุย) 20:32, 26 กรกฎาคม 2562 (ICT)